Bourbon remains one of the most popular American whiskeys, known for its distinct mash bill dominated by corn, its rich caramel and vanilla notes, and its deep connection to U.S. distilling traditions. While high-end bottles can easily cost over $100, a growing number of quality bourbons under $50 deliver remarkable flavor and character without the premium price tag. After extensive tasting, research, and market analysis, I’ve narrowed down the best available options that balance quality, accessibility, and value.
The Growing Demand for Affordable Bourbon
The bourbon market has experienced steady growth over the past decade, driven by renewed interest in American whiskey both domestically and internationally. While limited-edition releases and small-batch expressions draw attention among collectors, the majority of consumers seek bottles that offer everyday drinkability at a reasonable price.
Distilleries have responded by maintaining core product lines that meet quality expectations without inflating costs. Consistency is key , affordable bourbons need to be reliable from bottle to bottle, offering the same tasting profile that made them popular in the first place.
Criteria for Selecting the Best Bourbons Under $50
When evaluating the best bourbons in this price range, I focus on several key factors:
-
Mash bill composition – The ratio of corn, rye, and malted barley directly influences sweetness, spice, and mouthfeel.
-
Age statement – While not all quality bourbons list an age, those that do often provide insight into maturity and depth of flavor.
-
Proof level – Bottles between 90 and 100 proof tend to balance richness with approachability.
-
Availability – A great bourbon should be accessible in most markets without excessive hunting.
-
Flavor complexity – Even at this price point, a bourbon should deliver layered notes rather than a one-dimensional profile.
Each of the bourbons listed below meets these standards while offering distinct characteristics.
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Buffalo Trace has developed a loyal following due to its smooth, balanced profile and consistent quality. Produced at one of the oldest continuously operating distilleries in the United States, this bourbon features a mash bill that leans toward the sweeter side with subtle rye spice.
On the nose, it delivers vanilla, toffee, and light citrus. The palate follows with caramel, brown sugar, and a touch of baking spice, finishing with gentle oak. At around 90 proof, it’s approachable neat, on the rocks, or in classic cocktails like an Old Fashioned. Despite occasional scarcity in certain markets, its retail price remains under $50.
Wild Turkey 101
Known for its bold character, Wild Turkey 101 packs more punch than most bourbons in this price range. Its high rye content in the mash bill gives it a spicier edge without overwhelming the sweetness of the corn base.
At 101 proof, it offers a warm, full-bodied profile with toasted oak, vanilla, cinnamon, and rich caramel. The higher proof makes it ideal for sipping neat in cooler months, though it also holds up well in cocktails. For the price, it delivers depth and complexity that rivals more expensive bottles.
Four Roses Small Batch
Four Roses Small Batch blends four unique bourbon recipes from the distillery’s extensive library, creating a balanced, flavorful expression. It’s bottled at 90 proof, making it smooth yet flavorful.
The aroma features ripe red fruit, floral notes, and gentle spice, while the palate offers caramel, vanilla, and hints of nutmeg. Its mellow yet intricate profile works equally well as a casual sipper or as the base for whiskey-forward cocktails. This bottle consistently delivers excellent value in the under-$50 category.
Elijah Craig Small Batch
Elijah Craig has long been associated with quality bourbon, and its Small Batch expression maintains that reputation. Bottled at 94 proof, it offers a rich, full-bodied profile at a very accessible price.
Expect aromas of honey, toasted oak, and vanilla, leading into flavors of caramel, baking spices, and a touch of smoke. The finish is long and warming, making it an excellent year-round bourbon. It’s widely available, which makes it a reliable choice for regular stocking.
Maker’s Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Maker’s Mark is distinctive for its wheated mash bill, which replaces rye with red winter wheat. This results in a softer, sweeter flavor profile, making it approachable for those new to bourbon while still satisfying experienced drinkers.
The nose offers butterscotch, vanilla, and light fruit, with a palate of caramel, soft spice, and oak. At 90 proof, it’s exceptionally smooth neat but also blends beautifully into a Boulevardier or whiskey sour. Its iconic red wax seal and consistent quality make it a staple on many shelves.
Old Forester 100 Proof
Old Forester is one of the few distilleries to produce bourbon continuously before, during, and after Prohibition. The 100 proof expression is a favorite among bartenders for its bold flavor and versatility in cocktails.
It opens with baking spices, dark chocolate, and caramel, followed by a robust palate of oak, vanilla, and light citrus. The higher proof ensures it stands up in mixed drinks, but it’s also enjoyable neat. Priced well under $50, it’s a reliable, flavorful choice.
Knob Creek 9 Year Small Batch
Aged nine years and bottled at 100 proof, Knob Creek offers depth of flavor uncommon in this price range. It’s part of the Jim Beam portfolio but has its own distinct profile.
The aroma presents roasted nuts, vanilla, and caramel, with a palate of rich oak, dark fruit, and a hint of spice. The finish is long, warming, and satisfying. For those who enjoy a more mature bourbon, this is an exceptional value.
Evan Williams Single Barrel Vintage
Evan Williams Single Barrel is unique in this category because each bottle comes from a specific vintage year, meaning slight variations from batch to batch. Bottled at 86.6 proof, it offers a smooth, nuanced profile.
Notes include vanilla, honey, and light toffee, with a touch of spice and oak on the finish. It’s approachable for casual sipping but still complex enough for enthusiasts to appreciate the craftsmanship.
1792 Small Batch
1792 Small Batch is produced by Barton 1792 Distillery and offers a balanced, slightly spicier profile than many bourbons at this price point. Bottled at 93.7 proof, it delivers a rich caramel and vanilla base with layers of rye spice and oak.
Its bold yet balanced flavor makes it suitable for both sipping and mixing. It’s also widely distributed, making it easy to find.
Benchmark Full Proof
Benchmark Full Proof is bottled at 125 proof, making it the highest-proof bourbon on this list. Despite the high proof, it’s surprisingly balanced, with toffee, vanilla, and dark fruit flavors supported by a warm, lingering finish.
A splash of water opens up additional notes of spice and oak. For under $50, it offers a cask-strength experience that’s rare in this price range.
How Proof Level Affects Flavor
Proof plays a significant role in the drinking experience. Lower-proof bourbons, around 80–90 proof, tend to be smoother and more approachable, making them good for beginners or casual sipping. Higher-proof options, from 100 proof and above, deliver more intense flavors and can be diluted with water or ice to personal preference.
When selecting the best bourbon under $50 right now, I consider the intended use , whether for neat sipping, mixing in cocktails, or both.
Value in Everyday Drinking
One of the main advantages of this price range is that these bourbons can be enjoyed regularly without feeling like a special-occasion bottle. Consistency and reliability matter, especially when buying repeatedly. Many of these brands have long histories, proven track records, and dedicated followings that ensure quality control remains a priority.
Availability and Regional Variations
Availability can vary significantly by region. While some bourbons, like Maker’s Mark and Elijah Craig, are widely available nationwide, others like Buffalo Trace may be harder to find in certain states. When I find a preferred bourbon that’s less common, I tend to buy an extra bottle or two to avoid running out.
The Importance of Personal Taste
While professional reviews and tasting notes can help guide a decision, personal preference ultimately determines the right choice. I recommend sampling a few options from this list to see which profiles appeal most , whether that’s the soft sweetness of a wheated bourbon or the spiciness of a high-rye mash bill.
Final Thoughts
The best bourbon under $50 right now offers a combination of approachability, complexity, and value that makes it ideal for both seasoned enthusiasts and newcomers to the category. Whether it’s the smooth balance of Buffalo Trace, the bold spice of Wild Turkey 101, or the rich maturity of Knob Creek 9 Year, these bottles prove that great bourbon doesn’t have to be expensive. By focusing on flavor profile, proof, and availability, it’s possible to stock a reliable and enjoyable selection without exceeding a modest budget.
